Hi,
Thanks for reflecting on each point. Just some replies:
3. Yeah, it seems 😞 I find these improvised keyboard changes mind-blowing. Home/End/PgUp/PgDown/F11/F12 is basic functionality, even for someone who is just doing word processing, but even specialty applications use them. Also, why the heck mess up the numeric keyboard's calculator buttons and wire them together with F6 and such? I guess this could have been solved in software, so everyone using Windows' calculator is happy, while everyone using something else can use buttons for whatever. Could be a BIOS setting as well to switch between these modes of operation.
4. Yeah I have no doubt that Lenovo support staff is also not knowledgable, but at least for Thinkpads these used to be quite good WIKI pages and community support. For example, when Dell ships a notebook with Ubuntu, they install some custom Dell packages, that "make things work". For example make sure that the display brightness buttons work. However, if you install another distribution or just re-install ubuntu, these are no more available and there is no technical description anywhere, how it is working technically or where to get the custom Dell package. There are a lot of messy details like display brightness, Nvidia Optimus to switch between integrated and dedicated GPU, fingerprint reader, webcam, etc. I have no hands-on experience with recent Thinkpads, but the P16 may be better in this regard. Also the keyboard layout is way better, all the keys are present and located where god himself has put originally. I guess less SSD slots in the P16 is a downside, and also no CAMM (It says "Up to 128GB DDR5 4800MHz (4800MHz native, 4000MHz actual)" on the website). Also I have 3-4 Dell chargers which would go obsolete with the P16. I also wonder, if P16 gives a better docking experience or not. The recent Dell docking stations were not really supported by Linux (it worked for an hour, then shut off the external display).
5. It seems there is less and less we can replace, which was the main selling point for enterprise-class notebooks. The RAM we most likely won't replace due to CAMM, WWAN you just have or not have. Keyboard/Fan maybe interesting later on when there is no warranty any more, but these I guess harder to replace now. So it's basically the SSD which is left..