SuperMG Posted May 1, 2025 Posted May 1, 2025 Hello. I have a laptop with two MXM slots. I've had an NVIDIA GPU in master before. I was getting 60% TDP max in the slave card which is the Nvidia Quadro P5200. I wanted to get atleast 90-100% of TDP max usage. It's an Nvidia driver bug between two NVIDIA GPUs... and I thought one AMD GPU could fix that. Then I managed to find a working AMD card as the master GPU for my laptop. It's an Radeon HD 6990M. Both GPU drivers install but... Only the HD 6990M one seems to get the rendering capabilities. My NVIDIA is at 0% GPU usage everytime. I did the regedit hacks to set the high performance GPU but that didn't do anything. I used NVCleanInstall to install my Nvidia drivers. The AMD drivers are the Catalyst one from 2015 What's wrong with it?
ssj92 Posted May 1, 2025 Posted May 1, 2025 2 hours ago, SuperMG3 said: Hello. I have a laptop with two MXM slots. I've had an NVIDIA GPU in master before. I was getting 60% TDP max in the slave card which is the Nvidia Quadro P5200. I wanted to get atleast 90-100% of TDP max usage. It's an Nvidia driver bug between two NVIDIA GPUs... and I thought one AMD GPU could fix that. Then I managed to find a working AMD card as the master GPU for my laptop. It's an Radeon HD 6990M. Both GPU drivers install but... Only the HD 6990M one seems to get the rendering capabilities. My NVIDIA is at 0% GPU usage everytime. I did the regedit hacks to set the high performance GPU but that didn't do anything. I used NVCleanInstall to install my Nvidia drivers. The AMD drivers are the Catalyst one from 2015 What's wrong with it? Which registry edits did you do? Alienware Area-51M : Intel Core i9-9900K @ 5.3Ghz | nVidia GeForce RTX 2080 | AX210 | Samsung 970 Evo+ Alienware M18x R2 : Intel Core i7 3920XM @ 4.7Ghz | nVidia GeForce RTX 3080 | AX210 | Samsung 980 PRO Alienware 18 : Intel Core i7 4930MX @ 4.5Ghz | nVidia Quadro RTX 5000 | AX210 | Samsung 980 NVMe More Laps: M14x | M14xR2 | M15x (980m) | M17xR2 (RTX 3000) | M17xR3 (WX 7100) | M18xR1 (RTX 5000) Precision 7520 (T1000) | 7720 (Tesla P6) BEAST Server: Intel Xeon W7-3465X 28 P-Cores | 2x nVidia RTX Titan | 128GB RDIMM | Intel Optane P5800X CS Studios YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/CSStudiosYT
SuperMG Posted May 1, 2025 Author Posted May 1, 2025 (edited) 44 minutes ago, ssj92 said: Which registry edits did you do? The EnableMsHybrid ones and the DirectX regedit one. I just copied what you did on the other forum. I used the 2016 crimson drivers right now and now I can finally use my NVIDIA P5200 GPU. Not sure for how long... I think the old driver isn't fully compatible for windows 10 I got 5700 points on 3dmark TimeSpy with 129W TDP peak. Edited May 1, 2025 by SuperMG3
ssj92 Posted May 1, 2025 Posted May 1, 2025 42 minutes ago, SuperMG3 said: The EnableMsHybrid ones and the DirectX regedit one. I just copied what you did on the other forum. I used the 2016 crimson drivers right now and now I can finally use my NVIDIA P5200 GPU. Not sure for how long... I think the old driver isn't fully compatible for windows 10 I got 5700 points on 3dmark TimeSpy with 129W TDP peak. Post benchmarks for time spy and fire strike here so others can also see and compare in the future. So it seems like you got it working. Someone else is trying with R9 M290X and there's isn't working but they didn't do the directX part which is also needed Alienware Area-51M : Intel Core i9-9900K @ 5.3Ghz | nVidia GeForce RTX 2080 | AX210 | Samsung 970 Evo+ Alienware M18x R2 : Intel Core i7 3920XM @ 4.7Ghz | nVidia GeForce RTX 3080 | AX210 | Samsung 980 PRO Alienware 18 : Intel Core i7 4930MX @ 4.5Ghz | nVidia Quadro RTX 5000 | AX210 | Samsung 980 NVMe More Laps: M14x | M14xR2 | M15x (980m) | M17xR2 (RTX 3000) | M17xR3 (WX 7100) | M18xR1 (RTX 5000) Precision 7520 (T1000) | 7720 (Tesla P6) BEAST Server: Intel Xeon W7-3465X 28 P-Cores | 2x nVidia RTX Titan | 128GB RDIMM | Intel Optane P5800X CS Studios YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/CSStudiosYT
SuperMG Posted May 1, 2025 Author Posted May 1, 2025 32 minutes ago, ssj92 said: Post benchmarks for time spy and fire strike here so others can also see and compare in the future. So it seems like you got it working. Someone else is trying with R9 M290X and there's isn't working but they didn't do the directX part which is also needed here
SuperMG Posted May 2, 2025 Author Posted May 2, 2025 (edited) On 5/1/2025 at 7:39 PM, ssj92 said: Post benchmarks for time spy and fire strike here so others can also see and compare in the future. So it seems like you got it working. Someone else is trying with R9 M290X and there's isn't working but they didn't do the directX part which is also needed It always take the NVIDIA GPU now with the Crimson drivers. But I sometimes get an error on OpenCL... Load library failed with error 126. I tried to install NimeZ adrenaline drivers, it fixed the OpenCL issue but I can't no longer render from the NVIDIA GPU.... Why do they make things complicated. Just be smart when making drivers let people FORCE USE the preferred GPU. I broke everything... I reinstalled the crimson drivers now I get 20fps on heaven benchmark instead of 130fpS Edited May 2, 2025 by SuperMG3
SuperMG Posted 21 hours ago Author Posted 21 hours ago Hello. I've got news. I managed to get the AMD + NVIDIA combo to permanently work. Everything renders from the NVIDIA. DX9,10,11,12 and even OpenGL. How to do that: (WIP) Use a GCN 1.0 card such as the HD 7970M (Blue PCB, V1.2 from P15EL) for the Clevo X7200 Sadly I have the green version from MSI and I lost internal audio and warm boot. (Can't use the early vbios to fix that so I bought a V1.2 P15EL card, I'll receive it later). Use DDU software and remove any existing video drivers. Install both AMD (latest GCN1.0) and NVIDIA drivers. The order doesn't matter. After installing, go to regedit and create a DWORD in the AMD's driver folder to EnableMsHybrid 1 and for NVIDIA's driver folder to EnableMsHybrid 0. Then go to the UserGpuPreferences and add a new string called "DirectXUserGlobalSettings" to set the directX renderer to the NVIDIA GPUID. Value: SwapEffectUpgradeEnable=1;HighPerfAdapter=GPUID; REBOOT THE LAPTOP. Then go back to the registry and delete OpenGLDriverNameWow and OpenGLDriverName from the AMD's folder. Reboot again. Create OpenGLDriverNameWow and OpenGLDriverName in the AMD's folder but this time we'll swap the value with the NVIDIA's ones. Now you have both OpenGL and DX working from the Nvidia as slave! I can finally use the latest NVIDIA drivers because with a Kepler 1 GPU as the master, I was limited with the drivers and I couldn't use an RTX card in the slave. With AMD I can now! On Heaven benchmark 4.0 with AMD + GTX 970M, I gained 7FPS compared to the Nvidia K3000M/GTX 680M + 970M combo I had. 56FPS vs 63FPS, same settings, same resolutions, same CPU, same RAM, same operating system.
ssj92 Posted 19 hours ago Posted 19 hours ago 2 hours ago, SuperMG said: Hello. I've got news. I managed to get the AMD + NVIDIA combo to permanently work. Everything renders from the NVIDIA. DX9,10,11,12 and even OpenGL. How to do that: (WIP) Use a GCN 1.0 card such as the HD 7970M (Blue PCB, V1.2 from P15EL) for the Clevo X7200 Sadly I have the green version from MSI and I lost internal audio and warm boot. (Can't use the early vbios to fix that so I bought a V1.2 P15EL card, I'll receive it later). Use DDU software and remove any existing video drivers. Install both AMD (latest GCN1.0) and NVIDIA drivers. The order doesn't matter. After installing, go to regedit and create a DWORD in the AMD's driver folder to EnableMsHybrid 1 and for NVIDIA's driver folder to EnableMsHybrid 0. Then go to the UserGpuPreferences and add a new DWORD to set the directX renderer to the NVIDIA GPUID. REBOOT THE LAPTOP. Then go back to the registry and delete OpenGLDriverNameWow and OpenGLDriverName from the AMD's folder. Reboot again. Create OpenGLDriverNameWow and OpenGLDriverName in the AMD's folder but this time we'll swap the value with the NVIDIA's ones. Now you have both OpenGL and DX working from the Nvidia as slave! I can finally use the latest NVIDIA drivers because with a Kepler 1 GPU as the master I was limited with the drivers and I couldn't use an RTX card in the slave. With AMD I can now! On Heaven benchmark 4.0 with AMD + GTX 970M, I gained 7FPS compared to the Nvidia K3000M/GTX 680M + 970M combo I had. 56FPS vs 63FPS, same settings, same resolutions, same CPU, same RAM, same operating system. Interesting, might have to try this with my WX4150 instead of M2000M for RTX 5000 in slave slot. Pascal and older no longer receive drivers so my RTX 5000 uses a older driver now. Also I wonder if this can be a way to solve the dx12 issue in Optimus mode with intel hd 3000. In SG mode with hd3000 al dx12 gpus only work up to dx11 for some reason. So do you still run into the power limit issue? Alienware Area-51M : Intel Core i9-9900K @ 5.3Ghz | nVidia GeForce RTX 2080 | AX210 | Samsung 970 Evo+ Alienware M18x R2 : Intel Core i7 3920XM @ 4.7Ghz | nVidia GeForce RTX 3080 | AX210 | Samsung 980 PRO Alienware 18 : Intel Core i7 4930MX @ 4.5Ghz | nVidia Quadro RTX 5000 | AX210 | Samsung 980 NVMe More Laps: M14x | M14xR2 | M15x (980m) | M17xR2 (RTX 3000) | M17xR3 (WX 7100) | M18xR1 (RTX 5000) Precision 7520 (T1000) | 7720 (Tesla P6) BEAST Server: Intel Xeon W7-3465X 28 P-Cores | 2x nVidia RTX Titan | 128GB RDIMM | Intel Optane P5800X CS Studios YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/CSStudiosYT
SuperMG Posted 16 hours ago Author Posted 16 hours ago 2 hours ago, ssj92 said: Interesting, might have to try this with my WX4150 instead of M2000M for RTX 5000 in slave slot. Pascal and older no longer receive drivers so my RTX 5000 uses a older driver now. Also I wonder if this can be a way to solve the dx12 issue in Optimus mode with intel hd 3000. In SG mode with hd3000 al dx12 gpus only work up to dx11 for some reason. So do you still run into the power limit issue? For Pascal, the P3000 was maxing at 71W in furmark. It's a 70W GPU. I didn't test with anything newer or powerful yet.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now