Jump to content
NotebookTalk

Recommended Posts

Posted
2 hours ago, JadeRover said:

 

It depends if you have the 1 or the 2 motherboard.

 

- LA-9771P is a "dual LVDS + eDP motherboard", just like m6700 except that it has both signals on one connector, I talked previously on how to upgrade a LA-9771P motherboard to a "full" eDP motherboard (requires the correct cable "QHD lvds" + soldering an easy 4 pin jst "fan like" connector to the motherboard)

-> This version has NO MUX SWITCH between MXM slot and display. See the block diagram that shows this :

image.thumb.png.49dd333bc6a579f62564c270d25e54b3.png

 

The limit to bandwidth is signal integrity on the motherboard so 4K 100Hz+ should be doable, like on m6700 posts about 4K 105Hz on 51nb.

 

- LA-9772P is an "only eDP motherboard", like precision 7x10 and 7x20, to upgrade to 4k you just need the correct "4K eDP" display cable.

-> This version HAS A MUX SWITCH between MXM slot and display. See block diagram :

image.thumb.png.53e89ef0587112eb2f7b7c130d61fef4.png

 

It is the same mux switch as the Precision 7x10 and 7x20 so 4K at close to 100Hz possible as well just like @janepa showed.

Alienware M17X R4 has a 4 lanes eDP 40 pins connection but it has 2 PS8321 MUX switches... @sliderfratold me he got like a 1440p 120Hz display to work there? 

 

We can bypass the two muxes with wires directly to the EDP connector but that's going to be hard to do physically.

Posted

That's right ! 

 

image.thumb.png.9afa0f0a6b227ef99b75026099c03302.png

 

The output of one feeds into the other, this strange design is because it has an HDMi input port that must also be muxed into the the internal LCD, the laptop technically has QUAD MUX switches in case the laptop has an eDP or LVDS display, 2 for each display type, what a crazy design.

 

1440p 120Hz is possible with the PS8321, it operates at max HBR1 speed to 2.7Ghz, whereas the precision 7x10/7x20's mux operates at max HBR2 speed to 5.4Ghz, double the bandwidth in theory, 1440p 120Hz must really be pushing it.

 

19 minutes ago, SuperMG said:

We can bypass the two muxes with wires directly to the EDP connector but that's going to be hard to do physically.

 

Yes possible but very hard, I am thinking of doing this on my Zbook 17 g2, it has the same mux and I would like to fit a 4K 120hz display, this project will be far in the future though.

Precision M6700 : i7-3740QM | P3000 6gb engineering vbios | 20gb DDR3 1600Mhz | FHD ips dreamcolor | delta fans

Zbook 17 g3 : i7-6820HQ -75mv | M3000m 4gb | 16gb DDR4 2400Mhz | FHD ips 

Precision 7720 : i7-6820HQ -80mv & 102.7mhz BCLK| Zotac GTX1060 6gb, 100w OC vbios | 16gb DDR4 3011Mhz |  1440p165hz (upgrad)

Zbook 17 g5 : i7-8850H, -140mv | P5200 16gb | 32gb DDR4 2666Mhz | FHD IPS

 

Posted
1 hour ago, JadeRover said:

That's right ! 

 

image.thumb.png.9afa0f0a6b227ef99b75026099c03302.png

 

The output of one feeds into the other, this strange design is because it has an HDMi input port that must also be muxed into the the internal LCD, the laptop technically has QUAD MUX switches in case the laptop has an eDP or LVDS display, 2 for each display type, what a crazy design.

 

1440p 120Hz is possible with the PS8321, it operates at max HBR1 speed to 2.7Ghz, whereas the precision 7x10/7x20's mux operates at max HBR2 speed to 5.4Ghz, double the bandwidth in theory, 1440p 120Hz must really be pushing it.

 

 

Yes possible but very hard, I am thinking of doing this on my Zbook 17 g2, it has the same mux and I would like to fit a 4K 120hz display, this project will be far in the future though.

So the second one is like an override over the existing eDP/DP MXM signal? Because when you connect the HDMI IN, it displays the HDMI in contents on the edp screen but you need a driver to make that to work.

 

What about the MAX switch from the WirelessHD? I got the WirelessHD to work with an RTX 3080 MXM. It can only do max 1080p 60p at 60GHz? Or can I push further to 1440p using Nvidia's output settings?

 

Is the HDMI 1.4a limited at HBR1 speeds too? Possible for 1440p 75/100Hz?

Posted
25 minutes ago, SuperMG said:

What about the MAX switch from the WirelessHD? I got the WirelessHD to work with an RTX 3080 MXM. It can only do max 1080p 60p at 60GHz? Or can I push further to 1440p using Nvidia's output settings?

 

The MUX switch for the DMC (wireless Display) is the same model that is on the eDP connector so it can in theory do 1440p 165Hz or so (120Hz at least). However I think the bottleneck will be the wireless card and the transmission signal over distance, you can give it a try of course.

 

27 minutes ago, SuperMG said:

Is the HDMI 1.4a limited at HBR1 speeds too? Possible for 1440p 75/100Hz?

 

The HDMi is 2.25gbps so less than HBR1, maybe 1440p 60 Hz ? That's what the specs say, tbh I know more about DP/eDP than HDMi.

 

28 minutes ago, SuperMG said:

So the second one is like an override over the existing eDP/DP MXM signal? Because when you connect the HDMI IN, it displays the HDMI in contents on the edp screen but you need a driver to make that to work.

 

Yes, first the laptop selects between CPU and GPU for the "motherboard" signal -> get's fed into the second mux at the same time as the HDMi in -> get's sent to the display. So yes in a way it acts as an override.

Precision M6700 : i7-3740QM | P3000 6gb engineering vbios | 20gb DDR3 1600Mhz | FHD ips dreamcolor | delta fans

Zbook 17 g3 : i7-6820HQ -75mv | M3000m 4gb | 16gb DDR4 2400Mhz | FHD ips 

Precision 7720 : i7-6820HQ -80mv & 102.7mhz BCLK| Zotac GTX1060 6gb, 100w OC vbios | 16gb DDR4 3011Mhz |  1440p165hz (upgrad)

Zbook 17 g5 : i7-8850H, -140mv | P5200 16gb | 32gb DDR4 2666Mhz | FHD IPS

 

Posted
22 hours ago, JadeRover said:

Wow okay, That is promising, maybe I'll start thinking about making custom lcd cables if micro coax isn't required for 4K 100Hz !

 

Do you have pictures of the setup ? And also how did you connect the cable on the motherboard side, you also pushed in the flex cable ?

Actually maybe I read it wrong, you pushed the cable in on the LCD or on the Motherboard ?

All the modifications were actually made specifically for testing on a test bench, because I wanted to verify some information from this site: 

https://www.panoxdisplay.com/solution/edp-displayport-aux-channel-design-guide/

 

I was especially interested in connecting AUX pull-up and pull-down resistors when using a 4K LCD

and the initial EDID DPCD data sequence.

 

Unfortunately I didn’t take many photos during this testing, as I didn’t expect it to be particularly important. It’s been a while now, so I’ll try to find something, but there won’t be much.

 

My opinion however is that using it directly as a replacement for an LCD cable is not practical due to the width of the flat cable itself and frequent mechanical bending. I also remember that after several repeated insertions into the IPEX connector the contact areas of the flex cable were damaged (cut through).

lcd side.jpg

source side.jpg

lcd.jpg

Alienware M18x R1 i7-2720xm-32GB-Adlink RTX5000

Alienware M18x R2 i7-3920xm-32GB-RTX4090 (still in testing) with the latest bios version. A14 specially modified updated and unlocked by me 😎

Asus ROG Zephyrus G14 AMD Ryzen 9 7940HS-32GB-RTX4060

 

Posted
30 minutes ago, janepa said:

All the modifications were actually made specifically for testing on a test bench, because I wanted to verify some information from this site: 

https://www.panoxdisplay.com/solution/edp-displayport-aux-channel-design-guide/

 

I was especially interested in connecting AUX pull-up and pull-down resistors when using a 4K LCD

and the initial EDID DPCD data sequence.

 

Unfortunately I didn’t take many photos during this testing, as I didn’t expect it to be particularly important. It’s been a while now, so I’ll try to find something, but there won’t be much.

 

My opinion however is that using it directly as a replacement for an LCD cable is not practical due to the width of the flat cable itself and frequent mechanical bending. I also remember that after several repeated insertions into the IPEX connector the contact areas of the flex cable were damaged (cut through).

lcd side.jpg

source side.jpg

lcd.jpg

 

Thanks for the awesome pictures !

 

So how did you connect the flex cable to the laptop ? You soldered wires from the MXM slot to the 40 pin 0.5 connector splitter/merger and then used the flex cable to bring the signal to the LCD ?

 

33 minutes ago, janepa said:

My opinion however is that using it directly as a replacement for an LCD cable is not practical due to the width of the flat cable itself and frequent mechanical bending. I also remember that after several repeated insertions into the IPEX connector the contact areas of the flex cable were damaged (cut through).

 

I agree, a flex cable is not the best suited cable for this kind of connection, maybe custom LCD cable with simple none coax wires is possible.

 

What might be simpler is cutting the 2 aux lanes going from the GPU to the mux switch. We could solder an i2c eeprom on the bare eDP aux lines going to the GPU, with the loaded EDID of a known working eDP or standard DP lcd to trick the GPU drivers into not killing the signal.

Precision M6700 : i7-3740QM | P3000 6gb engineering vbios | 20gb DDR3 1600Mhz | FHD ips dreamcolor | delta fans

Zbook 17 g3 : i7-6820HQ -75mv | M3000m 4gb | 16gb DDR4 2400Mhz | FHD ips 

Precision 7720 : i7-6820HQ -80mv & 102.7mhz BCLK| Zotac GTX1060 6gb, 100w OC vbios | 16gb DDR4 3011Mhz |  1440p165hz (upgrad)

Zbook 17 g5 : i7-8850H, -140mv | P5200 16gb | 32gb DDR4 2666Mhz | FHD IPS

 

Posted

I created a kind of small pcb bridge to which I connected the lanes from the MXM, added control and power for the LCD display ,dc blocking capacitors , pull-up and pull-down resistors and then sent it all through the already mentioned flat cable to LCD.

 

Using all of this I verified that it worked, and then I proceeded directly to modify my own microcoaxial cable exactly to my needs, so it’s hard to say whether a non-coaxial cable harness would work. I really don’t know. The only way to check is to try assembling one and testing it. For me however it’s easier to modify a cable that’s already manufactured. Yes, it’s not easy, but it’s doable.

mxm.JPG

Alienware M18x R1 i7-2720xm-32GB-Adlink RTX5000

Alienware M18x R2 i7-3920xm-32GB-RTX4090 (still in testing) with the latest bios version. A14 specially modified updated and unlocked by me 😎

Asus ROG Zephyrus G14 AMD Ryzen 9 7940HS-32GB-RTX4060

 

Posted

Alright, that is very cool well done !

 

I see you are using your M18x r2/r1 motherboard as a test bench.

 

What you have done gives me the idea of a "universal" cable to drive any LCD from any MXM laptop : use a short flat flex cable, like the one @SuperMG made, stick it on the MXM card and have it take the 4 lanes of eDP + 1 lane of AUX from the card, slot the card in the laptop, then have the flex cable terminate to a universal 40 pin eDP connector -> use a pre made 40 pin to 40 pin eDP microcoax cable (very cheap  <10 euros aliexpress) and drive any eDP display you want, regardless if the laptop came with eDP or LVDS out of the factory, no mux switch. Even for an LVDS only laptop such a setup would work, maybe at the cost of losing one of the on board display port outputs.

 

This coming week I will do some tests on zbook 15 g3 if the cpu didn't die (shorted iGPU mosfet, haven't tested it yet), and see if I can get it to recognize an internal LCD with different EDIDs.

Precision M6700 : i7-3740QM | P3000 6gb engineering vbios | 20gb DDR3 1600Mhz | FHD ips dreamcolor | delta fans

Zbook 17 g3 : i7-6820HQ -75mv | M3000m 4gb | 16gb DDR4 2400Mhz | FHD ips 

Precision 7720 : i7-6820HQ -80mv & 102.7mhz BCLK| Zotac GTX1060 6gb, 100w OC vbios | 16gb DDR4 3011Mhz |  1440p165hz (upgrad)

Zbook 17 g5 : i7-8850H, -140mv | P5200 16gb | 32gb DDR4 2666Mhz | FHD IPS

 

Posted

Yes, it’s an R2. I have it as a spare board. Good guess.👍

 

There have already been a few similar ideas here on the forum, and even some even wilder ones. Unfortunately, I’m sure that for the large majority of platforms especially those with LVDS it won’t work. That’s because you need to modify the BIOS of each specific device to match the necessary requirements, especially for older platforms with LVDS (chipset configuration, ACPI table, and more). It’s a very,very long run. I know this from personal experience. Making such a “universal” cable would be the easiest thing of all.. But maybe it could work on newer platforms with full UEFI GOP support.

 

That’s exactly what needs to be tested on other platforms as well, such as the ZBook.

That would be great. Good luck.

Alienware M18x R1 i7-2720xm-32GB-Adlink RTX5000

Alienware M18x R2 i7-3920xm-32GB-RTX4090 (still in testing) with the latest bios version. A14 specially modified updated and unlocked by me 😎

Asus ROG Zephyrus G14 AMD Ryzen 9 7940HS-32GB-RTX4060

 

Posted
3 hours ago, JadeRover said:

Alright, that is very cool well done !

 

I see you are using your M18x r2/r1 motherboard as a test bench.

 

What you have done gives me the idea of a "universal" cable to drive any LCD from any MXM laptop : use a short flat flex cable, like the one @SuperMG made, stick it on the MXM card and have it take the 4 lanes of eDP + 1 lane of AUX from the card, slot the card in the laptop, then have the flex cable terminate to a universal 40 pin eDP connector -> use a pre made 40 pin to 40 pin eDP microcoax cable (very cheap  <10 euros aliexpress) and drive any eDP display you want, regardless if the laptop came with eDP or LVDS out of the factory, no mux switch. Even for an LVDS only laptop such a setup would work, maybe at the cost of losing one of the on board display port outputs.

 

This coming week I will do some tests on zbook 15 g3 if the cpu didn't die (shorted iGPU mosfet, haven't tested it yet), and see if I can get it to recognize an internal LCD with different EDIDs.

Yes but the problem is space, on some laptops you don't have space for the size of a micro controller inside and it'll cost lots of money to produce in a factory

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Terms of Use